No. Laser printers don’t use ink at all. They use toner, a dry powder that the printer fuses onto the paper with heat. Ink is a liquid, and it belongs in inkjet printers. The two aren’t interchangeable, and an ink cartridge won’t fit a laser printer or work in one.
The confusion is understandable. Most people still say “printer ink” for anything that goes in a printer, and online shops don’t always help. Before you order, check the model number on the front of the printer and buy the toner listed for that exact model.
How a laser printer prints
HP sums up the difference neatly: inkjets spray liquid ink as tiny droplets, while in a laser printer the toner is attracted to a charged drum, then fused onto the page with heat (HP, ink and toner explained).
In a little more detail: a laser draws an invisible electrical image of your page on a rotating drum. Toner powder sticks to that image, transfers onto the paper as it passes, and then goes through the fuser, a pair of heated rollers that melt it into the page. That’s why pages come out of a laser printer warm, and why the print doesn’t smudge when it gets damp. A liquid would never survive the fuser, which is the simplest way to see why the two kinds of printer can’t share supplies.
Toner and ink, side by side
| Laser (toner) | Inkjet (ink) | |
|---|---|---|
| What’s in the cartridge | Dry powder | Liquid ink |
| Pages per cartridge | Usually thousands | Usually hundreds, unless it’s a refillable tank model |
| Text | Sharp, even on plain paper | Good, can spread on cheap paper |
| Photos | Fair to good | Better, on photo paper |
| Sitting unused | Powder doesn’t dry out | Nozzles can dry and clog |
| Speed on long jobs | Fast | Slower |
For an office printing invoices, contracts, letters and forms every day, laser is the usual answer. Inkjet still makes sense for light, occasional printing, and for photos.
What it costs per page
A toner cartridge costs more than an ink cartridge, which puts people off. The number that matters is what each one costs per page, and you can work it out for any printer: divide the price of the cartridge by the number of pages it’s rated for.
With made-up round numbers: a $120 toner cartridge rated for 6,000 pages works out at 2 cents a page. A $30 ink cartridge rated for 300 pages works out at 10 cents a page. The cheaper cartridge is five times the price per page. Real figures vary a lot by model, so do the sum with the actual prices and ratings for the printers you’re comparing, and for color, do it for each cartridge.
That isn’t the whole cost. Paper, the printer itself, and on laser printers the drum and other parts that wear out with use all add to it. But it’s usually the biggest difference between two printers that cost about the same to buy.
Why the yield on the box varies
The page rating on a toner cartridge comes from a standard test. HP explains that yields are measured with methods set by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO/IEC 19752 for black-and-white toner and ISO/IEC 19798 for color), and that page coverage changes the result: photos and full-page graphics use far more toner than short text documents (HP).
The test pages are mostly white paper with some text and graphics on them. If your office prints dense spreadsheets, dark letterheads or full-page images, expect fewer pages than the box says. Your pages simply carry more toner than the test page does. The standard test is also why it’s better to compare printers using ISO ratings than whatever other figure a seller quotes.
Divide the price of the cartridge by the number of pages it’s rated for.
The drum: the part people forget
On some laser printers the drum is built into the toner cartridge, so you replace both together every time. HP notes that this is the case in many of its LaserJet printers. On others, the drum is a separate part that lasts through several toner cartridges and is replaced on its own schedule.
Neither is better in every case, but it changes the cost per page, so check which kind you’re buying. If faint marks repeat at the same spacing down every page, the drum is the usual suspect, and a new toner cartridge won’t fix it. Our companion post, do laser printers use ink?, goes through all the parts you’ll replace over a printer’s life.
Color laser printers
A color laser printer uses four toners: cyan, magenta, yellow and black. Each runs out on its own, so you replace them one at a time. Many business models let you carry on printing in black when a color runs out, but not all do, so check before you buy if that matters to you.
Color pages cost more than black ones on any printer, laser or inkjet, because they use more toner. Setting computers to print in black and white by default, and choosing color only when it’s needed, is the cheapest saving most offices can make.
Which suits your office
Start with how much you print, not the price of the printer:
- A few pages a week: an inkjet or a small laser printer will do. The printer’s price matters more than the cost per page.
- Every day, mostly text: a black-and-white laser printer, or a laser multifunction printer if you also scan and copy.
- Every day, with color: a color laser multifunction printer, sized to your page count.
- A busy shared machine: a copier-class multifunction printer, usually leased, with toner and service included.
One more point if you want your printers looked after under a service agreement: ours are built around laser devices, and inkjet printers aren’t covered, which is one more reason offices tend to standardize on laser.
How we can help
We supply HP and Brother business printers and Ricoh copiers, and look after them alongside the rest of your fleet. Under a managed print agreement, we monitor toner levels and ship cartridges before they run out, so nobody is ordering the wrong one online. If you’re not sure what you’re spending per page now, a no-obligation print assessment will tell you. Call (386) 252-2292. For more ways to bring the cost down, see our practical guide to cost-effective printing.