Two copier quotes land on the same desk. One is a little cheaper a month. The other includes more toner, or a shorter term, or a different price per color page. Put side by side, they look like they’re for the same machine at slightly different prices. Over five years they can be thousands of dollars apart, and the gap is almost never in the line people compare.
What a copier costs depends on far more than the machine, so this post doesn’t quote prices. It shows where the money goes and how to put two offers on the same footing.
The four parts of what a copier costs
The machine
This is the purchase price, or the lease payment that spreads it over a term. It depends on speed, whether it prints color, the largest paper size it takes (letter and legal, or 11 x 17 as well), paper trays, and finishing such as stapling, hole-punching or booklets. Options add up quickly, so it pays to buy what your office uses rather than what looks good on the spec sheet.
Service and supplies
On most business copiers, toner, parts, repairs and maintenance are covered by a service agreement priced per page: a rate for each black page and a higher one for each color page, read from the machine’s meter. This is usually the biggest cost over the life of the copier, and it’s the one buried in the small print.
Paper and staples
Usually yours to buy, whatever the agreement. Worth knowing, because it doesn’t shrink when the service rate does.
Getting it in and out
Delivery, installation, connecting it to your network and computers, setting up scanning, and at the end, collecting the machine and wiping its drive. Some providers include these. Others charge for each. Ask.
Why the color share matters more than the payment
Take some round, made-up numbers (not a quote and not a market price, just enough to show how it works). Say your office prints 6,000 pages a month, and the agreement charges 1 cent for a black page and 7 cents for a color page.
At 15 percent color, that’s 5,100 black pages ($51) and 900 color pages ($63): $114 a month. If color creeps up to 30 percent, it’s 4,200 black ($42) and 1,800 color ($126): $168 a month. Same office, same number of pages, $54 a month more, or $3,240 over a five-year term, and the lease payment hasn’t changed at all.
That’s why the first number to know before you compare anything is your own page count, split into black and color. Your current copier can tell you: the meter report is usually a menu or two deep on the screen, or your current provider can send it.
Over five years they can be thousands of dollars apart, and the gap is almost never in the line people compare.
Lease or buy
Leasing spreads the cost over a term and is how most businesses get a copier. Buying costs more up front and nothing a month after, but you still need a service agreement, and you own the machine when it’s old.
Leasing tends to suit offices that want a predictable monthly figure, want to replace the copier when the lease ends, and would rather keep cash for other things. Buying tends to suit offices with steady, modest printing that plan to keep the machine for many years and have the cash to spare. If you buy, ask your accountant about Section 179, which can let you deduct equipment in the year you buy it. If you lease, the end of the lease is where most of the surprises are, which we cover below.
Either way, compare the total over the same period. A purchase price against a monthly lease payment tells you very little.
Six things to check in any quote
These are where offers that look alike turn out not to be:
- What the service rate covers. Toner, drums, parts, labor and maintenance supplies, or only some of them? What’s excluded (paper, staples, damage, moving the machine)?
- Minimums and allowances. Are you billed for a minimum number of pages whether you print them or not? What happens if you print more?
- Annual increases. Many agreements raise the payment or the page rates each year. A small yearly percentage compounds over five years. We explain how to spot it in why your copier lease payment keeps going up.
- The end of the term. Do you return it, buy it at a fair market value, or own it for $1? How much notice do you have to give, and what happens if you miss the date? Some agreements roll on month to month at the same payment.
- Getting out early. Most equipment leases can’t be cancelled. If your business might change, ask now what the options are.
- The drive. Who wipes or destroys the copier’s storage when it leaves, and is that in writing?
For a closer look at the fees themselves, see copier lease cost: hidden fees and pricing explained.
How to put two offers side by side
Ask each provider for the same things: the monthly payment and term, the black and color page rates, any page minimums, the annual increase, what’s included at installation, and the end-of-term terms. Then work out each offer over the full term using your own page counts:
- payment times the number of months,
- plus black pages times the black rate, and color pages times the color rate, for the same months,
- plus any annual increases,
- plus any one-off charges at the start and end.
It takes twenty minutes with a spreadsheet, and it’s the only comparison that means much. If one provider won’t give you the numbers you need to do it, that tells you something too.
Getting the size right
The other way offices overpay is a copier that’s too big or too small. Too big, and you pay every month for speed and trays nobody uses. Too small, and it’s running flat out, jamming, and needing more service visits than it should. Size it to your page count, how many people share it, the paper sizes you use and the finishing you actually need. If you’re looking at cutting what you already spend on printing rather than buying something new, our guide to cost-effective printing starts there.
What we do
We sell and lease Ricoh, HP and Brother copiers and printers, and we size them to the office before we quote. Our quotes show the payment, the page rates and what’s included in plain terms, and we walk you through the end of the lease before you sign the start. If you’d like to see what’s available first, the Smart Configurator lets you build a setup and send it to us, or you can look at our copiers and multifunction printers. If you’d rather we compared your current agreement with what we’d offer, call (386) 252-2292.