Two quotes for the same copier can show monthly payments a long way apart, and the cheaper one is not always cheaper. One may include service and toner, the other not. One may tax the payment and quote it before tax. One may add a delivery charge on the first invoice and a return charge on the last.
The only fair way to compare them is the total over the whole term. This post goes through every line that makes it up, then works an example from start to finish.
Seven lines that make up the real cost
1. The lease payment
This pays for the machine and its options over the term. It depends on the equipment, the term length, the lease type (fair market value or $1 buyout) and your business credit. A longer term lowers the payment and commits you for longer. Our guide to copier leasing services explains the two lease types.
2. Service and supplies
Usually a separate agreement with the dealer, covering repairs, parts and toner. It’s billed in one of two ways:
- Per page. You pay a set rate for every black page and a higher one for every color page, read from the machine’s meter.
- An allowance plus overage. A fixed monthly charge covers a set number of pages, and pages over it cost extra.
Either is fine. What matters is that the allowance, if there is one, fits your real volume, and that you know what isn’t covered. Paper and staples almost never are.
3. Sales tax
Florida taxes leases and rentals of equipment. The state rate is 6%, and many counties add a discretionary surtax on top (Florida Department of Revenue). Check whether each quote shows the payment before or after tax, and ask how tax applies to the service charge too.
4. Property tax and insurance
During the lease, the leasing company owns the machine, and some leases pass its property tax on the equipment through to you as a separate charge. Many leases also require you to insure the equipment, or charge a fee if you don’t show proof of cover. Neither is unusual. Both should be in the quote, not discovered on the third invoice.
5. One-time charges
Delivery, installation, network and scanning setup, and removal of the old machine. Some dealers include these; others itemize them. Ask.
6. Increases during the term
Some agreements raise the service rate, or the payment itself, every year. A few percent a year doesn’t sound like much until you add it up across a five-year term. Our post on escalation clauses shows how to spot one.
7. The end of the term
On a fair market value lease, buying the machine at the end costs its fair market value at that time. Returning it may carry packing and shipping charges. And many leases renew automatically, sometimes month to month and sometimes for a full year, unless you give notice in a set window before the end. Missing that window is one of the most expensive mistakes in leasing.
The only fair way to compare them is the total over the whole term.
A worked example
The numbers below are invented to show the arithmetic. They’re not a quote and not a market average; put your own quote’s figures in their place.
Say a 48-month fair market value lease has a $250 monthly payment. Service is billed per page, and the office prints 5,000 black and 1,000 color pages a month. Delivery and setup are a one-time charge, and the county in this example adds a 0.5% surtax to the state’s 6%.
| Line | Example figure | Over 48 months |
|---|---|---|
| Lease payment | $250 a month | $12,000 |
| Sales tax on the payment (6.5% in this example) | $16.25 a month | $780 |
| Black pages (5,000 at $0.01) | $50 a month | $2,400 |
| Color pages (1,000 at $0.06) | $60 a month | $2,880 |
| Delivery and setup | $200 once | $200 |
| Total | $18,260 |
Spread over the term, that “$250 a month” lease costs about $380 a month. Add a yearly increase on the service rate, a property tax line or a return charge, and the gap widens. The lease may still be a good deal; you just can’t tell from the payment alone.
How to make two quotes comparable
Ask each dealer for the same things, in writing:
- The lease payment, the term and the lease type
- How service is billed, the rates for black and color pages, and any allowance
- What service covers, and what it doesn’t
- Whether figures include sales tax, and any property tax or insurance charges
- Every one-time charge, at the start and at the end
- Whether any rate increases during the term, and by how much
- The auto-renewal terms and the notice window
Then work out the total for each, the way the table above does. The leasing checklist puts these questions alongside the rest of the process.
Is buying cheaper?
Over a long life, sometimes. Buying removes the lease payment but not the service, the toner or the repairs, and you’re left with an aging machine at the end. It suits a low-volume office that plans to keep the machine for many years. For a shared copier that everyone depends on, most offices lease so the cost is spread out and the machine can be replaced at the end of the term.
How we quote a lease
We quote leases on Ricoh, HP and Brother machines from 12 to 63 months, as fair market value or $1 buyout, subject to credit approval. We size the machine from your actual usage, and we lay every line out separately so you can do the arithmetic above yourself. If you’d like to start by building the setup online, see online copier leasing. Otherwise our leasing and rentals page has the details, or call (386) 252-2292 and we’ll go through a quote you already have.