When an office starts shopping for a new phone system, the sales material arrives full of acronyms: PBX, VoIP, UCaaS, CPaaS. They sound like competing products. They’re really four ways of delivering the same basic thing, which is a phone number your customers can call and a way to get that call to the right person.
This post compares the types rather than brands, because the type you need narrows the choice far more than any one product does. Once you know which kind fits, comparing providers of that kind is much easier.
The four main types
On-site phone system (PBX)
PBX stands for private branch exchange. It’s a box, usually in a closet or a server rack, that connects your desk phones to each other and to the outside phone lines. Older ones connect to copper lines from the phone company; newer ones (called IP PBX) run over your network and connect to the outside world over the internet.
You buy it, you own it, and someone has to maintain it. Changes are made on the box, usually by a technician. When it’s paid for and still supported by the maker, it can be cheap to keep running. When it fails, or the maker stops supporting it, you’re replacing hardware.
Suits: an office that already has one that works, everyone in one building, and few changes from year to year.
Hosted phone system (cloud PBX or hosted VoIP)
VoIP stands for voice over internet protocol, which just means calls travel over the internet. In a hosted system, the PBX moves to the provider’s data center. You keep desk phones (or use computer and mobile apps), and you pay per user per month.
Changes are made in a web admin page. People can answer the business number anywhere with an internet connection. There’s no box in the closet to fail or replace. What you depend on instead is your internet connection, so a plan for when it goes down is part of the setup.
Suits: most small and mid-sized offices, especially with more than one location or with staff who work away from their desk.
Unified communications (UCaaS)
UCaaS stands for unified communications as a service. It’s a hosted phone system with video meetings, team chat and often texting in the same app. Someone can start a chat, turn it into a call and then a video meeting with a shared screen without switching programs.
The benefit is one app, one login and one bill. The catch is overlap: if your company already uses Microsoft Teams for meetings and chat, a UCaaS bundle can mean paying for those twice. In that case a hosted phone system alongside Teams may be the better fit.
Suits: offices that don’t already have a meetings and chat tool, or that want to replace a mix of separate ones.
Communications platform as a service (CPaaS)
CPaaS is a toolkit rather than a finished system. It gives software developers building blocks (send a text, place a call, run a voice menu) to build into their own applications. A company might use it to send appointment reminders from its scheduling software, or to add click-to-call to a customer portal.
Suits: businesses with developers, or with software that needs to send messages or calls on its own. Most small offices never need it directly, though some of the business software they use runs on it behind the scenes.
The type you need narrows the choice far more than any one product does.
Side by side
| On-site PBX | Hosted VoIP | UCaaS | CPaaS | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | Your building | Provider’s data center | Provider’s data center | Provider’s data center |
| How you pay | Buy up front, plus maintenance | Per user, per month | Per user, per month | Per text, call or minute |
| Who makes changes | A technician, on the box | You or your provider, online | You or your provider, online | Your developers |
| Works away from the office | Only with extra setup | Yes, with apps | Yes, with apps | Depends what’s built |
| Depends on your internet | Less, if on copper lines | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Comparing the cost fairly
The usual mistake is to compare the monthly per-user price of a hosted system with “nothing,” because the on-site system is already paid for. Over five years, the on-site system still costs something: maintenance, the phone lines it uses, a technician for each change, and eventually a replacement. A hosted system costs the monthly fee, the desk phones (bought or included) and a reliable internet connection, which most offices already need.
Write both columns out over the same period, with your actual bills, before deciding. Sometimes the on-site system wins, usually when it’s nearly new and the office rarely changes. More often the hosted system comes out ahead once the hidden costs are counted.
Questions that narrow it down
- Is the current system still supported by its maker, and when does any lease or maintenance contract end?
- Do people need to answer the business number away from their desk?
- Do you have more than one location?
- Do you already pay for a video meeting and chat tool?
- How reliable is your internet connection, and is there a second one?
If you answered yes to the second or third question, a hosted system is usually the place to start. If the fifth answer worries you, fix the connection before moving anything.
Once you’ve picked the type, our post on getting started with cloud-based unified communications covers the move itself, and our plain guide to communication tools covers what each piece is for.
What we install
We set up hosted VoIP phone systems for businesses in Central Florida and the Daytona area: your numbers moved over, desk phones and apps installed, call routing set up, and texting from the business number. We support it afterward, and we’ll tell you honestly if the system you have now is worth keeping for a few more years.