A copier lease starts at $320 a month. Four years later the invoice says $374, for the same machine, and nobody remembers agreeing to a price increase. In most cases nobody did, at least not knowingly. The increase was agreed on the day the lease was signed, in a clause most people skim past.
It’s called an escalation clause (or an escalator), and it’s one of the most common reasons a copier bill creeps up over the life of a lease. This post explains how it works, what it adds up to, and what you can do about it, both before you sign and when the lease comes up for renewal.
What an escalation clause is
An escalation clause lets the leasing company or service provider raise a charge by a set percentage at set intervals, usually once a year on the anniversary of the lease. In the example above, the charge went up 4% a year: $320 became $333, then $346, then $360, then $374.
The increase may apply to the equipment payment, but it often applies to the service side instead: the per-page rates or the monthly service charge. Sometimes it applies to both. The wording is usually short, something like “charges may be increased annually by up to X%,” and it often sits in the service terms rather than on the page with the payment.
What it adds up to
A small percentage doesn’t look like much in year two. It compounds, though, because each increase is applied to the already-increased figure. The table shows a $300 monthly charge over a 60-month lease at three different rates. The rates are examples, not what any particular company charges.
| Yearly increase | Monthly charge in year 5 | Total over 60 months | Extra compared with no increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | $300 | $18,000 | $0 |
| 3% | $338 | $19,113 | $1,113 |
| 5% | $365 | $19,892 | $1,892 |
| 10% | $439 | $21,978 | $3,978 |
You can do the same sum for your own lease: take the current charge, apply the rate once for each year that’s left, and add up twelve months of each year. If you have several machines on the same terms, multiply.
Each increase is applied to the already-increased figure.
Why the clause is there
The companies that include escalators say they cover rising costs over a long term: toner, parts and technicians’ wages all get more expensive, and a service provider that has fixed its price for five years carries that risk.
That’s a fair argument as far as it goes. The trouble is that the clause usually lets the provider raise prices whether or not its costs went up, by a rate it chose, and it’s rarely pointed out when the lease is sold. You can accept an escalator knowingly, as part of a lower starting price. What you want to avoid is finding it in year three.
Where to look in your lease
Get out your lease and any service agreement that came with it, and look for:
- The escalation rate. Look for words like “increase,” “adjust” or “annual.” Note the percentage and how often it applies.
- What it applies to. The equipment payment, the service charge, the per-page rates, or all of them.
- Whether it’s “up to” a rate or a fixed rate. “Up to 5%” means the provider can pick any figure to 5%.
- Whether it compounds. Almost all do, but check.
- The renewal terms. What happens to the rate if the lease renews automatically at the end.
If you can’t find the clause but your bill has gone up, ask the provider in writing which clause allowed it.
What you can do about it
Before you sign
Ask every dealer the same question: can any charge in this lease or service agreement increase during the term, and by how much? Then compare quotes on the total over the term, including the increases, not on the first month’s payment. Our copier lease cost post shows how to compare two quotes that way.
If there’s an escalator, you can ask for it to be removed, capped at a lower figure, or limited to the service charges only. Some providers will agree, some won’t. Even a refusal tells you something about the total you’ll actually pay.
If you’re already in a lease
You usually can’t change the clause in the middle of a lease, but you can plan around it. Work out what the remaining increases will cost you, and mark the date your lease ends and the notice window before it. Many leases renew automatically if you don’t give notice, often on the same terms, escalator included.
At renewal
The end of a lease is when you have the most choice. You can renew with your current provider and ask for better terms, upgrade the equipment, move to another provider, or reassess how much you print. Renewal offers tend to be written in the provider’s favor, so compare them against at least one other quote before you sign.
Questions people ask about escalation clauses
Are escalation clauses legal?
Yes. They’re an ordinary contract term, and once you’ve signed, they’re generally enforceable. That’s why the time to deal with one is before you sign. If you think your provider has charged more than the clause allows, ask them to show you the calculation; if that doesn’t settle it, talk to your attorney.
Can I get a lease without an escalation clause?
Often, yes, or with a lower cap. Ask for it before you sign, and get the answer in writing in the agreement itself.
Does the clause apply to the equipment payment or the service?
It depends on the contract. Many escalators apply only to the service charges or per-page rates, but some apply to the whole bill. Read both the lease and the service agreement.
How we handle it
When we put together a lease, we walk you through every charge before you sign, including anything that can change during the term, and what happens at the end. Our copier leasing guide for small businesses covers the other clauses worth reading.
If you’re in a lease that costs more every year and you’re not sure what you agreed to, send it to us. We’ll tell you honestly whether you could do better, including manufacturer programs that may help. See leasing and rentals or call (386) 252-2292.