← All posts
Print & DocumentCopier maintenance

Lease or Buy a Copier? How Maintenance Works Either Way

Owning the machine and keeping it running are two separate decisions.

When a business weighs leasing a copier against buying one, the conversation usually turns to the monthly payment, the purchase price and taxes. The question that decides how the next five years actually go comes up later, often after the first breakdown: who fixes it, and who pays?

The answer surprises people. Leasing or buying decides who owns the machine. It doesn’t decide who maintains it. That’s a separate agreement, and you need to think about it either way.

Two decisions, not one

A copier lease is a way of paying for the machine. Keeping it running (toner, drums, parts, repairs, a technician when needed) is usually covered by a service agreement, which can be paired with a lease or with a machine you bought. You can lease a copier with no service agreement, which is rarely wise, and you can buy one and put it under a full service agreement.

So the useful question is “how do we want to pay for the machine, and how do we want to pay for keeping it running?”

If you lease

Most leased copiers come with a service agreement, often billed per page, covering toner, parts and labor. The two are frequently sold together and appear on one invoice, but they’re still separate obligations.

That matters on a bad day. Under most equipment leases, your duty to make the lease payments doesn’t depend on whether the machine works. If the copier is unreliable, your complaint is with whoever services it, and the lease payment is still due. Our copier lease agreement post explains why.

What leasing does settle is the end of the machine’s life. When the term ends you can return it and upgrade, so you’re not left maintaining an aging copier whose repairs get more frequent and more expensive.

If you buy

Owning the machine leaves you three ways to keep it running.

A service agreement

The same kind of agreement a leased machine would have: supplies, parts and labor for a charge based on pages printed, or a flat charge. You know the cost in advance, and the provider has a reason to keep the machine healthy because they pay for the repairs.

Pay per call

You buy toner as you need it and pay for each repair visit, parts and labor, when something breaks. In a quiet year this can cost less. In a bad year, a fuser and a couple of call-outs can cost more than a year of a service agreement, and you can’t budget for it. You’re also the one who notices when toner is low and orders it.

Do it yourself

For small desktop printers, this is often the sensible choice. They’re cheap enough that a major repair isn’t worth paying for, and replacing the printer is the fix. For a business copier, it rarely works: the parts and the know-how needed to replace them aren’t something an office keeps.

Leasing or buying decides who owns the machine. It doesn’t decide who maintains it.

The $1 buyout, in between

A $1 buyout lease ends with you owning the machine. Plan for what happens to service after that. The machine is now as old as your lease was long, repairs come more often as parts wear, and for older models some parts become harder to get. If you plan to keep it, make sure a service agreement continues after the lease ends, and ask what it will cost.

Comparing the cost honestly

Comparing the lease payment with the purchase price leaves out most of the cost. Compare over the same period, say five years, and include on each side:

  • the machine: lease payments, or the purchase price;
  • supplies: toner, drums and other consumables, at your real print volume;
  • repairs and maintenance: under an agreement, or your best estimate of calls and parts if you pay per call;
  • the time your staff spend ordering supplies and arranging repairs;
  • what happens at the end: return and upgrade, or a five-year-old machine you still own.

Buying usually comes out cheaper on the machine itself, because a lease includes financing. Whether it’s cheaper overall depends on the maintenance side, and on how long you keep the copier. If breakdowns are the worry, our post on what copier downtime really costs helps you put a number on them.

Which suits you

Buying, with a service agreement

This suits an office with steady volume that plans to keep one machine for years and has the cash to buy it.

Leasing, with a service agreement

This suits an office that wants a fixed monthly cost, wants to keep its cash, and wants to replace the machine on a schedule rather than when it gives out.

Paying per call

This suits small printers, and offices that print very little, where a service agreement would cost more than the repairs it covers.

For what a maintenance agreement should include, whichever way you go, see our guide to copier maintenance services.

How we handle it

We lease and sell copiers and printers, and we’ll tell you which makes more sense for your office. Either way, a managed print agreement covers parts, labor, toner and maintenance supplies, with remote monitoring and toner shipped before it runs out; you supply the paper and staples. Our agreements are built around laser devices, so inkjet printers aren’t covered.

For lease terms and end-of-lease options, see leasing and rentals, or call (386) 252-2292.

More on Print & Document

Let's build your foundation.

Tell us where your business is today and we'll help map the next step.