An office printer is cheap to buy and expensive to own. The bills that follow it around (toner, a fuser, a call-out when it stops) arrive on different invoices from different suppliers, often paid on someone’s company card, so nobody ever sees the total.
Published averages for “annual printer maintenance” are close to useless, because the answer depends almost entirely on how much you print and what kind of machine it is. What you can do is add up your own. This is how.
Five costs that come after the purchase
1. Toner or ink
This is usually the biggest one. To find what it costs per page, divide the price of a cartridge by the number of pages it’s rated to print. Most manufacturers rate black toner yields under an ISO test (ISO/IEC 19752) that uses a standard page of mostly text. If your pages carry more ink than the test page, such as forms with dark boxes, color logos or photos, you’ll get fewer pages per cartridge than the box says.
Color machines need four cartridges, and each one runs out at its own pace, so a color page costs more, often a lot more, than a black one.
2. Parts that wear out on schedule
Laser printers have parts designed to be replaced after a set number of pages: the drum (on some models it’s built into the toner cartridge), the fuser that melts toner onto the paper, the transfer roller or belt and the feed rollers that pick up each sheet. Many manufacturers sell these together as a maintenance kit. The printer’s manual or its status page tells you each part’s rated life, and the printer usually warns you when one is due.
These aren’t repairs, they’re running costs. Budget for them by page count, the same way you budget for toner. Our post on what’s in a maintenance kit goes through the parts one by one.
The drum is worth a second look when you compare printers. On many HP LaserJet models it’s built into the toner cartridge, so its cost is already in the cartridge price. On many Brother models it’s a separate unit that outlasts several toner cartridges. Neither is automatically cheaper, so compare the two together, per page.
3. Repairs
Everything that isn’t on schedule: a cracked gear, a failed sensor, a paper path that keeps jamming. Without a service plan, each repair is a call-out charge plus parts plus labor, and the printer is down until the technician arrives.
A common rule of thumb: if a single repair on an out-of-warranty printer would cost more than half the price of a comparable new one, replace it instead.
4. Downtime and staff time
This one never gets an invoice. Count the time people spend clearing jams, ordering toner, chasing a technician and walking to another printer. As an example with made-up figures, if the office loses 20 minutes a day to the printer across everyone, that’s around 80 hours over a working year, or two full working weeks.
5. Power and paper
Smaller, but real. Paper is the same on any machine, though two-sided printing as the default cuts it sharply. Power depends mostly on how much the printer draws while idle, which is most of the day; ENERGY STAR certified models are built to use less.
How to add it up for your office
You need about twenty minutes and last year’s invoices.
- Count pages. Print the printer’s configuration or usage page. It shows the total page count. Compare it with a reading from a few months ago, or divide by the printer’s age, to get pages a year.
- Toner cost per year. Pages per year divided by the cartridge’s rated yield, times the cartridge price. Do black and color separately.
- Wear parts per year. For each part, pages per year divided by its rated life, times its price.
- Repairs. Add up the last twelve months of repair invoices.
- Time. Estimate the hours spent on the printer, times a rough hourly cost.
A worked example for steps 2 and 3, with round numbers chosen only to show the math: a $150 toner cartridge rated for 6,000 pages is 2.5 cents a page. A $120 drum rated for 30,000 pages adds 0.4 cents. A $300 maintenance kit rated for 150,000 pages adds 0.2 cents. That printer costs about 3.1 cents a page in supplies before paper, repairs or anyone’s time. Rated lives assume light coverage (Brother, for example, rates its maintenance parts at 5 percent coverage on letter paper), so graphics-heavy pages will get fewer.
Do this for every printer, including the small ones on desks. Desktop printers are often the most expensive per page in the building, because their cartridges are small, and a desktop printer doing a workgroup’s printing also wears out early.
Service plan or pay as you go
Pay as you go costs nothing until something breaks. It suits a single, lightly used printer where an occasional repair bill is easy to absorb.
A service plan turns the unpredictable costs into a known one. On a managed print agreement, the provider usually covers toner, wear parts and repairs, often billed per page, and watches the machine remotely so toner ships before it runs out and faults are caught early. It suits offices with several printers, a copier that everyone depends on, or nobody who wants to be the printer person.
To compare fairly, put your own total from the steps above next to the plan’s price for the same volume. If the plan is close to what you already spend, the difference is the time and the surprise bills you stop dealing with.
Desktop printers are often the most expensive per page in the building.
Five ways to bring the number down
- Retire the desktop printers nobody needs. Fewer, better-placed machines cost less per page and are easier to look after.
- Make two-sided and black and white the defaults. People can still choose color; they just have to mean it.
- Use secure release. Jobs print only when the person is at the machine, so pages nobody collects are never printed.
- Keep the basics clean. A wipe of the rollers and the glass, paper stored sealed and dry, and firmware kept current prevent a lot of call-outs. Our printer maintenance tips cover the routine.
- Replace wear parts when they’re due, not after they’ve damaged something else.
One caution on toner: some compatible cartridges are fine and some aren’t, and a leak inside the printer can ruin a drum or a fuser, which costs more than the toner saved. Our post on choosing a compatible toner cartridge covers what to check.
What we do about it
Under a managed print agreement with us, parts, labor, toner and maintenance supplies are covered, and you supply the paper and staples. We watch your devices remotely, ship toner based on actual levels and fix problems remotely where we can before sending a technician. If you’d like to see your own numbers first, a no-obligation print assessment maps every device, what it prints and what it costs. Call (386) 252-2292.